12 Nostrand Avenue, Brentwood, New York

Brentwood · Central Suffolk County, Long Island

12 Nostrand Avenue.

A colonial built in 2014, five bedrooms and four full baths, with a heated saltwater pool and its own pool house in the back yard.

Offered At

$750,000

5

Beds

4

Baths

3,800

Sq. Ft.

0.45

Acres

Now Showing

12 Nostrand Avenue, Brentwood

Active · OneKey MLS KEY426471682

The Residence

Built In 2014, Kept That Way.

Nostrand Avenue runs through the middle of Brentwood, in the Town of Islip, where the parkways cross Suffolk County and the Great South Bay is a short drive south. The house was built in 2014 and sits on 19,602 square feet — a little under half an acre — with the pool and the pool house set behind it.

The main level holds a spacious living room, a family room, a formal dining room and a well-appointed kitchen. Upstairs, the expansive primary suite has walk-in closets and an en-suite bath with a jetted tub and a separate shower. Four full baths serve the house. The finished basement adds living space that can be assigned whatever job you need done.

Outside is the argument. A heated salt combo in-ground pool, a pool house with a full bathroom, and open ground around both for chairs, a table, or nothing at all. An attached garage handles the car and everything that accumulates near it. Leased solar panels sit on the roof, working on the electric bill.

The whole house shares one birthday. Roof, systems, windows and finishes all date to 2014, and the place has been beautifully maintained since. Three thousand eight hundred square feet across five bedrooms means the rooms are sized to be used, not admired from the doorway.

Tour & Plans

Walk it before you walk it.

A full Matterport capture of the house — walk it room to room at your own pace, as if you were standing in it. Measured floor plans below.

Specifications

Everything on the record.

Location

The Middle of Suffolk.

Brentwood sits in the Town of Islip, roughly centered between the Long Island Expressway to the north and the Southern State Parkway to the south, with the Sagtikos State Parkway running the north–south connection. The Brentwood station on the LIRR Ronkonkoma Branch is close by. The Michael J. Grant Campus of Suffolk County Community College is in Brentwood. South of here, Bay Shore leads to the Great South Bay and the Fire Island ferries. The school district is Brentwood.

Schools · Brentwood

The Numbers

Priced against the field.

Seven hundred fifty thousand dollars against 3,800 square feet of interior, five bedrooms, four full baths, and 19,602 square feet of land. Construction dates to 2014, so the roof, systems and finishes carry the same age. Annual taxes are $13,508. The pool, pool house and finished basement are included in those numbers.

Closed sales from OneKey MLS, pulled August 12, 2026. Comparable sales are provided for context and are not an appraisal.

Address Bd/Ba Sq. Ft. $/Sq. Ft. Sold
Private Showing

See it before the weekend.

Showings are by appointment. Send a note and you'll hear back the same day — or call directly, which is usually faster.

Listed By

Peter C. Grosso

Licensed Real Estate Broker · CBR

RE/MAX Integrity Leaders

Both lines are answered 24/7 — ask anything about the property and you'll get an answer straight away.